There has recently been discussion in the Mozilla community about Opera switch from Presto to Webkit and the need to preserve browser competition and diversity of rendering engines, especially with mobile devices. Some people outside the community seem a bit skeptic about that argument. Perhaps a striking example to convince them is to consider the case of MathML where basically only Gecko has a decent native implementation and the situation in the recent eBooks workshop illustrates that very well: MathML support is very important for some publishers (e.g. for science or education) but the main eBook readers rely exclusively on the Webkit engine and its rudimentary MathML implementation. Unfortunately because there is currently essentially no alternatives on mobile platforms, developers of eBook readers have no other choices than proposing a partial EPUB support or relying on polyfill....

After Google's announce to remove MathML from Chrome 25, someone ironized on twitter about the fact that an Acid test for MathML should be written since that seems to motivate them more than community feedback. I do not think that MathML support is something considered important from the point of view of browser competition but I took this idea and started writing MathML versions of the famous Acid2 and Acid3 tests. The current source of these MathML Acid tests is available on GitHub. Of course, I believe that native MathML implementation is very important and I expect at least that these tests could help the MathML community ; users and implementers.

Here is the result of the MathML Acid2 test with the stable Gecko release. To pass the test we only need to implement negative spacing or at least integrate the patch I submitted when I was still active in Gecko developments (bug 717546).

MathML Acid2 test ; Gecko

And here is the score of the MathML Acid 3 test with the stable Gecko release. The failure of test 18 was not supposed to happen but I discovered it when I wrote the test. That will be fixed by James Kitchener's refactoring in bug 827713. Obviously, reaching the score of 100/100 will be much more difficult to achieve by our volunteer developers, but the current score is not too bad compared to other rendering engines...

MathML Acid 3 ; Gecko